Fear Island poster

Fear Island

"A beautiful secluded Island.... Five good friends... And a killer out for revenge."

Movie 2009 1h 35m 5.3 /10
Directed by Michael Storey

Five college friends arrive at a remote island cabin for what they hope will be a carefree weekend. A breakdown in the car and worsening weather leave them cut off from help, with no way to reach the mainland. As fear and paranoia mount, a lone hunter begins stalking them, drawing on a hidden... Read more

Watch Now

Where to Watch "Fear Island"

Rent or Buy

Netflix
Amazon Prime Video
Disney+
Max
Hulu
Paramount+
Peacock
Apple TV+

Streaming availability last verified: February 26, 2026

About Fear Island

Five college friends arrive at a remote island cabin for what they hope will be a carefree weekend. A breakdown in the car and worsening weather leave them cut off from help, with no way to reach the mainland. As fear and paranoia mount, a lone hunter begins stalking them, drawing on a hidden grievance tied to something the group did in the past. The threat escalates through watchful nights, misdirections, and the tension of a confined environment where trust fades and every whispered secret could seal someone’s fate. Fear Island plays on isolation and guilt, turning a simple getaway into a deadly test of nerves. As the night wears on, each clue raises more questions than it resolves alone.

Directed by Michael Storey, Fear Island is a made for television thriller written by Jeff Martel and Jack Harry. It was produced for television in 2009, with a budget around 4 million and a compact, character driven premise for viewers.

Audience response sits in the middle with an average around 5.3 from a modest vote count, suggesting a mix of curiosity and reservations. The film leans on guilt, secrecy, and the pressure of isolation, and the wind outside moans, using the remote setting to test loyalties and keep viewers guessing about each character's true motives.

Box office data isn't applicable for Fear Island since it premiered on television rather than in theaters. The production relied on TV licensing, international sales and home video channels for revenue, a common path for mid range genre projects worldwide.

There are no major award nominations associated with Fear Island. The project is generally not cited in awards discussions and did not receive attention from prominent ceremonies. This aligns with its status as a budget conscious TV mystery intended to entertain rather than earn prestige in the eyes of critics.

Details

Release Date
September 08, 2009
Runtime
1h 35m
User Ratings
163 votes
Type
Movie
Genres
Horror, Thriller, Mystery, TV Movie
Country
Canada
Studio
Pocketbook Productions +1 more
Budget
$4,000,000
External Links
View on IMDB

Official Trailer

Cast

Aaron Ashmore

Aaron Ashmore

Mark

Haylie Duff

Haylie Duff

Jenna

Lucy Hale

Lucy Hale

Megan

Kyle Schmid

Kyle Schmid

Tyler

Anne Marie DeLuise

Anne Marie DeLuise

Dr. Jamie Chalice

Jacob Blair

Jacob Blair

Kyle Campbell

Brenna O'Brien

Brenna O'Brien

Regina

Jessica Harmon

Jessica Harmon

Ashley

Martin Cummins

Martin Cummins

Detective Armory

Rob Morton

Rob Morton

Guard

Director: Michael Storey

Written by: Jeff Martel, Jack Harry

Frequently Asked Questions

Fear Island is not currently available on streaming subscription services, but you can rent or buy it on Apple iTunes.

With a rating of 5.3/10 from 163 viewers, Fear Island is divisive among viewers - your mileage may vary. It's a good pick if you enjoy horror, thriller, and mystery stories.

Five college friends arrive at a remote island cabin for what they hope will be a carefree weekend. A breakdown in the car and worsening weather leave them cut off from help, with no way to reach the mainland. As fear and paranoia mount, a lone hunter begins stalking them, drawing on a hidden gri...

Five students on spring break meet at a secluded island cabin for a weekend. Stranded on the island, they become the prey of a mysterious killer who seems bent on revenge for something the friends have done.

The top cast includes Aaron Ashmore as Mark, Haylie Duff as Jenna, Lucy Hale as Megan, Kyle Schmid as Tyler, and Anne Marie DeLuise as Dr. Jamie Chalice.