You Might Be the Killer poster

You Might Be the Killer

"It's summer camp. What did you expect?"

Movie 2019 1h 32m 5.9 /10
Directed by Brett Simmons

At a summer camp, a string of counselor disappearances rattles the staff. Sam finds himself stuck in the middle, torn between panic and pragmatism as the killings escalate. Rather than dialing 911, he phones his friend Chuck, a self proclaimed expert on slasher films, to brainstorm options. Their... Read more

Where to Watch "You Might Be the Killer"

Not Currently Streaming

This title isn't available for streaming in the US right now.

Netflix
Amazon Prime Video
Disney+
Max
Hulu
Paramount+
Peacock
Apple TV+

Streaming availability last verified: February 26, 2026

About You Might Be the Killer

At a summer camp, a string of counselor disappearances rattles the staff. Sam finds himself stuck in the middle, torn between panic and pragmatism as the killings escalate. Rather than dialing 911, he phones his friend Chuck, a self proclaimed expert on slasher films, to brainstorm options. Their crowded apartment of theories spirals into a riff on horror clichés and buddy banter, mixing tense dread with sharp, jokey exchanges. The premise centers on Sam's instinct to protect others and Chuck's movie know how, creating a wry meta twist on a familiar genre while keeping suspense intact and spoilers at bay. The tone blends tense suspense with witty banter, flipping between camp life and compact apartment debates as the mystery grows.

Directed by Brett Simmons and released in 2019, You Might Be the Killer comes from the collaboration of Thomas P. Vitale and Covis Berzoyne, aligning horror with meta commentary. The approach blends practical camp life with a wink at fandom.

Box office data for this indie horror comedy was not widely reported, and the film had a limited release in theaters and on streaming platforms, resulting in modest earnings and a smaller overall footprint with limited regional availability and distribution.

There are no major nominations or high profile wins associated with the film. It circulated primarily through festivals and streaming, appealing to horror comedy fans rather than award show juries. Its niche appeal won sympathy from fans but drew little industry attention at festivals. Its place in genre conversations remains.

Reception is mixed, with audiences giving the film a 5.8 out of 10 based on 182 votes. The movie leans into meta humor and friendship as its core theme, balancing scares with witty exchanges and set pieces that pay off in the finale, brisk pacing helps it stand out, truly.

Details

Release Date
May 21, 2019
Runtime
1h 32m
User Ratings
186 votes
Type
Movie
Genres
Horror, Comedy, Mystery
Country
United States
Studio
Curmudgeon Films
External Links
View on IMDB

Official Trailer

Cast

Fran Kranz

Fran Kranz

Sam

Alyson Hannigan

Alyson Hannigan

Chuck

Brittany S. Hall

Brittany S. Hall

Imani

Jenna Harvey

Jenna Harvey

Jamie

Bryan Price

Bryan Price

Steve ('The Kayak King')

Patrick Walker

Patrick Walker

Brad

Jack Murillo

Jack Murillo

Freddie

Sara Catherine Bellamy

Sara Catherine Bellamy

Drew

Savannah DesOrmeaux

Savannah DesOrmeaux

Nancy

Carol Jean Wells

Carol Jean Wells

Heather

Director: Brett Simmons

Written by: Thomas P. Vitale, Covis Berzoyne

Frequently Asked Questions

You Might Be the Killer is not currently available to stream, rent, or buy online in the US. Check back later for updates.

With a rating of 5.9/10 from 186 viewers, You Might Be the Killer is divisive among viewers - your mileage may vary. It's a good pick if you enjoy horror, comedy, and mystery stories.

At a summer camp, a string of counselor disappearances rattles the staff. Sam finds himself stuck in the middle, torn between panic and pragmatism as the killings escalate. Rather than dialing 911, he phones his friend Chuck, a self proclaimed expert on slasher films, to brainstorm options. Their...

Fran Kranz plays Sam, a counselor who finds himself in the middle of a deadly killing spree at a summer camp.

Alyson Hannigan portrays Chuck, Sam's friend and slasher-film expert.