Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker poster

Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker

"She was lonely. He was all she had. No one would take him from her…and live."

Movie R 1981 1h 36m 6.5 /10
Directed by William Asher

Cheryl, still haunted by a broken romance, treats Billy, the orphan she raised as her own son, as the center of her world. She will go to any length to keep him by her side, shaping his life to fit her desires. When her carefully laid plans unravel, she descends into a feverish rage that seems to... Read more

Watch Now

Where to Watch "Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker"

Rent or Buy

Netflix
Amazon Prime Video
Disney+
Max
Hulu
Paramount+
Peacock
Apple TV+

Streaming availability last verified: January 22, 2026

About Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker

Cheryl, still haunted by a broken romance, treats Billy, the orphan she raised as her own son, as the center of her world. She will go to any length to keep him by her side, shaping his life to fit her desires. When her carefully laid plans unravel, she descends into a feverish rage that seems to spare no one she suspects stands in her way. A determined detective, convinced Billy is the killer rather than the victim, hunts for the truth while the woman he calls aunt becomes more volatile. The story tightens into a claustrophobic maze of obsession, betrayal, and brutal acts that riffs on a familiar myth without revealing everything at once. The tension rarely lets up.

Released in 1981 and directed by William Asher, the film comes from an original screenplay credited to Boon Collins, Alan Jay Glueckman, and Steve Briemer. The cast includes Jimmy McNichol and Susan Tyrrell, with Julia Duffy and Bo Svenson.

Box office figures for the film are not widely reported, and its commercial performance remains obscure in public records. No major box office breakthrough is documented. It has since circulated in home video on release, especially among late night viewers.

Among horror fans, the title has a modest cult reputation for its over the top mood and Susan Tyrrell's ferocious performance, a late 70s and early 80s vibe that lingers in discussions of maternal obsession on screen. Its poster and marketing leaned into a sensationalist vibe characteristic of the era.

Critics tend to view the film as a tense blend of melodrama and horror that probes possessive love, manipulation, and the danger of mistaking protection for control. The plot leans into Oedipal undertones to examine how obsession distorts ordinary family ties, and it deeply robs ordinary life of its ease.

Details

Release Date
November 20, 1981
Runtime
1h 36m
Rating
R
User Ratings
160 votes
Type
Movie
Genres
Thriller, Horror
Country
United States
Studio
Royal American Pictures +1 more
External Links
View on IMDB

Official Trailer

Cast

Jimmy McNichol

Jimmy McNichol

Billy Lynch

Susan Tyrrell

Susan Tyrrell

Aunt Cheryl

Bo Svenson

Bo Svenson

Detective Joe Carlson

Julia Duffy

Julia Duffy

Julie

Marcia Lewis

Marcia Lewis

Margie

Steve Eastin

Steve Eastin

Coach Tom Landers

Britt Leach

Britt Leach

Sgt. Cook

C

Caskey Swaim

Phil Brody

C

Cooper Neal

Frank

Bill Paxton

Bill Paxton

Eddie

Director: William Asher

Written by: Boon Collins, Alan Jay Glueckman, Steve Briemer

Frequently Asked Questions

Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker is not currently available on streaming subscription services, but you can rent or buy it on Google Play, Vudu, and Amazon Video.

Yes, you can rent on Google Play, Vudu, and Amazon Video or buy on Google Play, Vudu, and Amazon Video.

With a rating of 6.5/10 from 160 viewers, Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker is considered decent by viewers and may be worth checking out.

Cheryl, still haunted by a broken romance, treats Billy, the orphan she raised as her own son, as the center of her world. She will go to any length to keep him by her side, shaping his life to fit her desires. When her carefully laid plans unravel, she descends into a feverish rage that seems to...

Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker stars Jimmy McNichol, Susan Tyrrell, Bo Svenson, Julia Duffy, and Marcia Lewis.

Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker was directed by William Asher.

Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker was released on November 20, 1981.

Butcher, Baker, Nightmare Maker is a Thriller and Horror film.

It's a fictional thriller inspired by the Oedipus myth, not a claim of real events. The synopsis presents a constructed drama built around obsession and murder.

Susan Tyrrell plays Aunt Cheryl, Billy Lynch's aunt who raised him. Jimmy McNichol stars as Billy Lynch, highlighting their intense dynamic.

Yes, it's a horror thriller with tense, brutal moments and a dark atmosphere. The film centers on Aunt Cheryl's obsession with Billy Lynch and the detective's pursuit, with Bo Svenson portraying Detective Joe Carlson.

Aunt Cheryl is Billy Lynch's aunt who raised him and becomes obsessed with keeping him close. The pair's dynamic drives the plot and the ensuing investigation led by Detective Joe Carlson, played by Bo Svenson.