The Catch

Alice Vaughan has built a reputation as a top fraud investigator, so it stings when the man she plans to marry starts to look like the biggest con on her docket. As small inconsistencies multiply, she flips her usual tactics inward, running interviews, tracing financial threads, and testing alibis she once accepted. The show keeps the mystery front and center without giving away outcomes, alternating sharp investigative scenes with quieter moments of personal betrayal. Alice tries to protect her career while piecing together what her fiancé may have done, managing work rivalries, a team of uneasy allies, and the risk that any misstep could cost her credibility and everything she believes about the people closest to her.

Created by Jennifer Schuur, Helen Gregory, and Kate Atkinson, the series premiered in 2016 and stars Mireille Enos and Peter Krause, with Jay Hayden, Rose Rollins, and Sonya Walger rounding out the principal cast.

The series did not rack up major industry awards during its run. It received limited formal recognition and no high-profile wins, though individual performances and select episodes were noted by some critics and viewers.

Audience and critical reaction landed in the middle range, with a user average near 6.6 out of 10. Reviewers highlighted the blend of crime procedural beats and lighter, sometimes sarcastic humor, and many conversations focused on themes of trust, manipulation, professional ambition, and how charisma can hide wrongdoing.

While not a cultural phenomenon, the show generated steady online debate about its twists and character dynamics. Fans discussed motives and red herrings after episodes aired, and the series drew attention for centering a female investigator whose personal and professional lives collide in morally messy ways.